Is Your Cost-per-Click Advertising Actually Profitable?by Glen Hamilton
Shopping portals, comparison-shopping sites, and search engines
allow merchants to promote increasingly detailed merchandising offers
with the goal of cost-effectively increasing brand visibility,
acquiring new customers, and driving incremental revenues.
But how does an online retail merchant ensure that third-party
shopping destinations and other referral-based merchandising channels
contribute to the bottom line?
The answer lies within back-end retail line-of-business systems that
handle inventory, purchasing, order, and customer data—systems not
traditionally associated with online marketing, but critical to online
retail marketing success.
More Meaningful Metrics
The online retail marketer wants to know which combinations of
product assortments, channels, and merchandising offers will yield the
highest return against key retail planning metrics—which are not
typically incorporated into online advertising campaigns or management
systems.
Online advertising performance is traditionally measured by
click-through rate (CTR), conversion rate (CR), cost per acquisition
(CPA) and return on ad spend (ROAS):
- CTR is the percentage of site visitors that result from an online ad pageviews.
- CPA is the cost to acquire a new transaction or customer through a marketing channel.
- ROAS represents the sales revenue generated per dollar spent on an online marketing channel or a given ad within that channel.
- CR refers to the percentage of referred visits to your site that convert to a sale.
Unfortunately, these de facto standards for measuring advertising
performance are misaligned with the most important measures of retail
success. What retailers need to know to make informed advertising
decisions is how a given product that's promoted through a given
channel contributes to key retail metrics.
For retailers, these metrics typically include average order value
(AOV), gross profit (GP), gross profit margin (GPM), gross profit
margin return on investment (GPROI), gross margin return on inventory
investment (GMROII) and life-time value (LTV):
- AOV ($) = sales / number of orders
- GP ($) = sales - cost of goods sold
- GPM (%) = (sales - cost of goods sold) / sales
- GPROI (%) = (sales - cost of goods sold) / cost of goods sold
- GMROII ($) = gross profit ($) / average inventory at cost
- LTV ($) = present value of the gross profit from a given customer over a projected period of time.
The last of these retail metrics, LTV, is the present value of a
projected future stream of profit from a customer. Many factors go into
loyalty, retention and repeat sales; but, fundamentally, the retailer
must be able to segment and track customers by online channel to
understand the return on LTV of an online marketing dollar spent.
GMROII (pronounced "gym-roy") is a measure of merchandising
efficiency as it relates to revenue, inventory, and gross profit. The
goal is to maximize sales and profit margin while minimizing the
dollars held in inventory investment. The higher the GMROII percentage
or dollars, the better return a given SKU or assortment is giving the
retailer.
Applying Retail Metrics to Online Advertising
To calculate these retail metrics for online advertising campaigns,
the merchant must have the ability to marry sales, conversion, and ad
spend information from online marketing channels with retail planning
data, including per-product cost of goods sold (COGS) and average
inventory values.
The union of online advertising metrics and retail planning metrics
produces critical retail measures of the business impact of online
advertising campaigns, such as gross profit return on ad spend
(GPROAS), gross profit per order (GPO), gross profit per acquisition
(GPA):
- GPROAS (%) = gross profit ($) / ad spend
- GPO = gross profit ($) / number of orders
- GPA = gross profit ($) / number of new customers
Knowing Whether You Acquired the Customer
Referral-based advertising channels are attractive because the
retailer pays only for targeted traffic. The cost to acquire an order
is generally lowest through these channels, but the question remains:
Did you really acquire the customer? If you did, how much did that
customer really cost you, and just how profitable is the customer?
If the referring channel has more affinity to the consumer than the
retailer's ecommerce site, the customer may be referred back to the
retailer over and over again, reducing or eliminating the profitability
of that customer.
Loyalty, retention, and life-time value of the customer metrics are
key to understanding whether the customers that are served through a
given channel are really profitable. When you are able to segment and
track your customers by their channel of acquisition and calculate the
ongoing online marketing costs for each customer, you are in a position
to know whether you have acquired a profitable customer (or one that is
trending toward profitability).
Taking Action: Manage Your Online Ad Spend to Key Retail Metrics
Knowing where to spend more of your online advertising budget to
realize greater returns against key retail metrics is fundamental to
competitive online ad spend optimization, yet most online marketing
management or bid management tools are incapable of capturing and
processing the retail information needed to easily optimize ad spend on
these terms.
Progressive retailers are turning toward technologies and solution
providers that can optimize SKU-level or item-specific merchandising as
measured against these key metrics.
Your brand image is critical, but if you're not thinking about
merchandising in terms of the most detailed product attributes and
variables—pricing, title, description, keywords—you're not fully
leveraging available merchandising control. If you're not measuring the
impact of your merchandising effort by key retail metrics, you're
missing out on an opportunity to drive the strategic value of every ad
dollar.
You should be able to segment and identify customers acquired
through each online channel, not only so that they are properly costed
but also so that their loyalty, retention, and profitability may be
evaluated over time. A natural first step in collecting this
information is to source-code your click-through URLs and append
customer records with acquisition-source and cost-of-acquisition data.
If you have a homegrown online marketing tracking and reporting
system, start by adding product cost and inventory turns to your return
on investment calculations. If you use third-party tools or an
advertising agency, insist that the online channel advertising
solutions used are informed by your back-end retail line-of-business
systems. Even the basic inclusion of product cost and inventory values
will transform your online marketing approach.
Information on customer valuation combined with the ability to
report against your key retail metrics as a function of your online ad
spend—by SKU, by online channel, and over time—will give you the
ability to make every click count toward improved top-line revenue,
inventory velocity, and profitability.
If you're interested in learning more, consider attending our double header seminars on March 8 & 9: Essentials of Paid Search Marketing and Advanced Topics in Paid Search Marketing. Or buy the recordings and listen to them any time.
MarketingProfs.com
Become a Premium Member

Glen Hamilton is VP of product management at the Mercent Corporation (www.mercent.com).